LETTER TO CIT -V MR M C KATHERIA ON 9-12-2003

FROM:
P.S. SHRI
S.S. MODI
40 BMM SOCIETY
AHMEDABAD 380 006

9-12-2003


COMMISSIONER OF INCOME TAX –V
NARAYAN CHAMBERS
AHMEDABAD


SIR,


This is in reference to the letter addressed to the assessing officer on 8-12-2003 and 17-10-2003. I am also drawing your attention to my letters addressed to you, one on 3-6-2003 and another on 4-6-2003.

I gather that the concerned Mr. Kashiparekh has neither attended nor the department has taken any steps to call Mr. Kashiparekh, the auditor of Rupmanglam and Flovin Plastics Pvt Ltd.

This comfirms that the department lacks the courage to call the auditor concerned and others involved and both you and the department are pawns and servants of the tax advocates and auditors and you do not have any shame in behaving this way and you do not even want to value and protect the prestige, dignity of the revenue department.
In case you do not submit detailed findings and action taken report to me by tomorrow morning , it confirms that the tax advocate and the auditor are your personal touts and that of the department which prevents you to probe them as commissioner of income tax. and you are a traitor to the revenue department by not having guts to call them in interest of natural justice to the undersigned.

You need to be personally ashamed as you are tarnishing the image of the income tax department and if you were personally ashamed of your conduct, then you would
be compassionate enough to write apology letter addressed to me

I am enclosing an article from Gujarat samcahar on 7-12-2003 - ekaj de chingari, so that you do some serious introspection about your conduct and conduct of staff working under you.

Yours sincerely,

Pankaj s Mody